![]() |
|
![]() |
David Kincaid, John Whelan featured musicians in the Hollywood film "Gods and Generals." |
|||||||||
|
New York, Feb. 15, 2003.- One of the films outstanding themes is that of the heavy Irish involvement in the conflict, which often tragically pitted them against each other as soldiers of both the Union and the Confederacy. Contacted in July, 2001 by the films music producer, David Franco, to offer advice on the subject of Irish music in the American Civil War, |
||||||||||
|
John Whelan, Ron Maxwell and David Kincaid at the Maryland set.
Kincaid provided the arrangement for a period Irish Confederate lyric called Song of the Rebel Irish by the films producers -actually entitled Song for the Irish Brigade by its author, an Irish Confederate known only as "Shamrock" of the "Sumter Rifles," This lyric came with no accompanying music notation or tradtional Irish melody listed (it was common in those days to compose lyrics to well-known melodies), and Kincaid, who had adapted and arranged it a few years before for his upcoming album The Irish-Americans Song, had delved into the limitless archives of traditional Irish melodies to find one to fit, eventually landing upon a tune called "Martinmas Time." With a lot of finessing, this melody was gradually made to work with the lyrics unusual phrasing. Although a composer in his own right, David Kincaid is a staunch believer in the use traditional melodies for such purposes, rather than writing his own in keeping with the ancient Irish bardic tradition. |
![]() |
|||||||||
| John Whelan (2nd from left), David Kincaid (4th from left)-scene of the Irish Brigade just prior to its march to the battle of Fredericksburg, VA. | ||||||||||
| Following this Mr. Franco recruited Kincaid and Whelan to take part in two musical scenes - both Union and Confederate. The first was as part of the Irish Brigade as it marched off to take part in the Dec. 13th, 1862 battle of Fredericksburg, Va. This very brief scene, filmed in November, 2001, required a small band of Irish field music, comprised of three fellows playing tin whistle, John Whelan on button accordion, and David Kincaid on the bodhrán (Irish drum). The producers selected The Boys of the Irish Brigade, which they found on Kincaids album The Irish Volunteer, as the appropriate tune for the scene. The bands performance of the tune was recorded live on the set, to which they later lip-synced for the filming.
The second, and much bigger scene, was that of a Confederate minstrel show, put on for the likes of Confederate Generals Robert E. Lee (Robert Duvall) and Stonewall Jackson (Stephen Lang), along with their staffs and hundreds of Rebel troops. The song performed was the Rebel anthem The Bonnie Blue Flag, composed by vaudevillian-style performer Harry McCarthy, known as the Arkansas Comedian, to the old Irish tune The Irish Jaunting Car. David Kincaid, this time on banjo and backing vocals, and John Whelan on button accordion, were teamed up with the 2nd South Carolina String Band -renowned for their talents in conjuring up the sound and spirit of the Southern minstrel show of the Civil War era. The tune was first |
||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||
|
Confederate minstrel band, consisting of The 2nd South Carolina String Band (left to right: Bob Beeman, Chris St. Peter, Fred Ewers, Dave Goss, Joe Ewers, Greg Hernandez-far right), with David Kincaid and John Whelan. |
||||||||||
| recorded by all the above at Sound on Sound Studios in New York City on November 28th, 2001. In December, they traveled to the film set in Maryland to appear in the concert scene, the filming of which would span an entire day-from dawn to dusk. In between takes, while waiting for the right lighting or the setting up of different camera angles, the band would launch into impromptu renditions of Civil War tunes for Mr. Duvall & Co. The spontaneity of the day was infectious, and a great time was had by all.
David Kincaid, along with Capt. Michael Kraus, Orderly Sgt. Craig Geppert, and other members of Co. I, 116th Reg't PV, Irish Brigade -one of reenactings longest standing units- also had the honor of participating in some of the films several battle scenes, with Kincaid appearing as a company commander, and Kraus as Brig. General in the 20th Maines charge on Maryes Heights at the battle of Fredericksburg. Also part of Kincaids company in the filming was the Wild Geese Todays own co-editor, Joe Gannon. With 15 years experience as a Civil War reenactor, serving nine years as an NCO, four as an officer, Kincaid found the experience to be one of his most memorable and gratifying. |
||||||||||
![]() |
![]() |
|||||||||
|
Slate for the Confederate minstrel show scene. |
||||||||||
|
David Kincaid, Gen. Robert E. Lee (Robert Duvall). |
||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||
|
Confederate minstrels; 2nd SC Band with Gen. Stonewall Jackson (Stephen Lang), David Kincaid & John Whelan to his right. |
||||||||||
![]() |
Lt. David Kincaid (left), Lt. Col. Joshua L. Chamerlain, (Jeff Daniels), 20th Maine charge at Frederickburg. | |||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||
|
Pre-dawn makeup, film set near Frederick, Maryland, Dec. 2001.
|
Sgt. Fitzgerald (Ben Shaeffer) sings "Song of the Rebel Irish," or "Song for the Irish Brigade," adapted and arranged by David Kincaid.
|
|||||||||
|
Related Sites: Gods and Generals, Ron Maxwell, John Whelan, 2nd South Carolina String Band, Michael Kraus Historic Sculpture, THE IRISH AMERICANS SONG- |
||||||||||